Book Review: The JFK Conspiracy: The Secret Plot to Kill Kennedy—and Why It Failed by Brad Meltzer and Josh Mensch

The Forgotten Plot: How One Man Almost Changed History

This post may contain affiliate links at no extra cost to you. Please read our full disclosure here to find out more.

Few moments in American history are as heavily scrutinized and debated as the assassination of President John F. Kennedy. The tragic events of November 22, 1963, have inspired countless books, theories, and investigations. However, what if Kennedy’s presidency had never even begun? The JFK Conspiracy: The Secret Plot to Kill Kennedy—and Why It Failed by bestselling authors Brad Meltzer and Josh Mensch sheds light on a chilling, little-known episode in history—the first assassination attempt on JFK before his inauguration.

Written with the gripping, page-turning intensity that has become Meltzer and Mensch’s trademark, this book brings to life the story of Richard Pavlick, a disgruntled, anti-Catholic extremist who meticulously planned to kill Kennedy in December 1960. Had Pavlick succeeded, he would have rewritten American history before Kennedy could deliver his iconic inaugural address, face the Cuban Missile Crisis, or inspire a generation with his vision of landing a man on the moon.

A Forgotten Threat That Almost Changed History

Most Americans are familiar with Lee Harvey Oswald, but Richard Pavlick remains a footnote—until now. The book takes readers deep into the mind of this disturbed loner, a 73-year-old retired postal worker fueled by paranoia and hatred. Meltzer and Mensch meticulously detail how Pavlick, convinced that Kennedy’s Catholicism was a threat to America, transformed himself into a would-be assassin. Over three weeks, he purchased dynamite, packed his 1950 Buick with explosives, and stalked Kennedy, waiting for the perfect moment to strike.

The authors capture the eerie tension of December 11, 1960, when Pavlick sat in his car outside the Kennedy family compound in Palm Beach, Florida. He was prepared to detonate his vehicle the moment the president-elect stepped out. But fate intervened—Kennedy was not alone. Seeing Jackie Kennedy and their young children, Pavlick hesitated, unwilling to murder an entire family. This moment of pause spared Kennedy’s life, but the threat did not end there.

Four days later, Pavlick was arrested, thanks to a sharp-eyed New Hampshire postmaster who had grown suspicious of Pavlick’s erratic behavior and alerted authorities. The book explores how this seemingly insignificant intervention by a diligent postal worker changed the course of history.

Masterful Storytelling That Reads Like a Thriller

Meltzer and Mensch are at their best when weaving historical fact with a storytelling style that rivals top-tier thrillers. While The JFK Conspiracy is a work of nonfiction, it moves with the speed and suspense of a crime novel. The authors build tension through vivid scene-setting and deep psychological exploration, making readers feel as if they are right there, experiencing the high stakes of the moment.

One of the most compelling aspects of the book is its insight into Kennedy himself. Unlike other biographies that focus on his presidency, this book highlights his vulnerabilities—his brushes with death during World War II, the rampant anti-Catholic sentiment he faced during his campaign, and his almost reckless disregard for personal security. The book also examines how JFK’s near-assassination was largely overlooked by the public and media at the time, overshadowed by other major events like a tragic mid-air plane collision that dominated headlines.

A Window into America’s Political Landscape

Beyond telling the story of a nearly forgotten assassination attempt, The JFK Conspiracy delves into the broader historical and social context. The authors explore how deep-seated religious and political tensions of the era played a role in shaping the hatred that drove Pavlick. The book draws connections between the hostility Kennedy faced as the first Catholic president and the modern era of political division, conspiracy theories, and lone-wolf attacks on public figures.

The parallels to today are striking. Just as Kennedy faced virulent opposition from religious extremists, today’s leaders continue to battle misinformation and politically motivated threats. Meltzer and Mensch don’t just recount history—they make it feel relevant and urgent.

Why This Book Matters

History lovers, political junkies, and fans of true crime will all find something to love in The JFK Conspiracy. It’s not just a story about an assassination attempt—it’s a sobering reminder of how fragile history can be and how the actions of one person can alter the fate of a nation.

The book also forces readers to confront an uncomfortable reality: we often ignore near-misses in history. While we endlessly analyze the assassination that did happen, we fail to appreciate the one that almost did. Had Pavlick succeeded, America’s trajectory would have been irrevocably different.

Final Verdict: A Must-Read Thriller of History

Meltzer and Mensch have once again delivered a masterpiece of historical storytelling. Their ability to turn overlooked moments of history into compelling narratives is unmatched. If you love books that blend history with the intensity of a thriller, The JFK Conspiracy is a must-read. It’s a fast-paced, fascinating, and deeply informative book that sheds new light on one of the most important figures of the 20th century.

This book is not just an exploration of what almost happened—it’s a lesson in vigilance, history, and the unpredictable nature of fate. Don’t miss your chance to uncover this forgotten chapter of American history.

Get your copy of The JFK Conspiracy: The Secret Plot to Kill Kennedy—and Why It Failed today on Amazon and experience history like never before!

Buy "The JFK Conspiracy" on Amazon now!